The cushion cut is one of the most popular engagement ring shapes — but also one of the most varied. Cushion brilliant vs cushion modified brilliant, crushed ice vs chunky facets, depth traps, and the absence of a GIA cut grade make it a shape that rewards careful evaluation. This guide covers all the key decisions.
| Type | GIA designation | Visual character | Also called |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cushion brilliant | "Cushion Brilliant" | Bold, chunky flashes. Distinct arrow pattern in some cuts. Classic look. | Antique cushion, chunky cushion |
| Cushion modified brilliant | "Cushion Modified Brilliant" | Fragmented, diffuse sparkle. No distinct arrows. Shimmering, watery appearance. | Crushed ice cushion |
Both types have the same cushion outline — the difference is entirely in the pavilion facet arrangement. The crushed ice style (modified) has dominated the market for over a decade; the chunky antique cushion style has been growing in popularity as buyers seek a more vintage aesthetic. Neither is superior — choose the one you prefer visually. See our vintage diamond guide for antique cut context and our old mine cut glossary for the historical precursor.
Cushion cuts can be cut very deep — and a deep cushion retains more carat weight in the pavilion while appearing smaller face-up than a shallower stone of the same weight. This is a specific issue with cushion cuts that affects value for money:
Compare the listed dimensions (length × width) against our diamond size chart to check whether a cushion is spread appropriately for its carat weight. See our depth percentage glossary.
| Grade (1ct, GIA) | Round brilliant range | Cushion range | Discount approx. |
|---|---|---|---|
| G VS2 | $5,500–$8,000 | $4,000–$6,000 | ~20–25% |
| H SI1 | $3,500–$5,000 | $2,600–$4,000 | ~18–22% |
| I VS1 | $4,000–$5,500 | $3,000–$4,500 | ~18% |
Benchmark current prices at CaratAtlas (CC BY 4.0). Cushion cuts offer a meaningful price discount versus round brilliants of equivalent grade — this discount, combined with the cushion's large face-up size for its weight, makes it one of the best value fancy shapes. Verify the GIA certificate at GIA Report Check.
A cushion cut is a square or rectangular diamond with rounded corners and curved sides — the outline resembles a pillow or cushion. It is one of the most popular engagement ring shapes, combining a classic silhouette with the brilliant-cut facet arrangement (maximising light return). Modern cushion cuts are descended from the old mine cut of the Georgian and Victorian eras — the "pillow" outline is the same, but modern cushions are cut to much tighter specifications. Cushion cuts are not standardised in the way round brilliants are — there is significant variation in facet arrangement, depth, and visual character among cushion stones.
These are the two main cushion cut types GIA distinguishes on grading reports: "Cushion Brilliant" has a standard brilliant facet arrangement adapted for the cushion outline — similar to a round brilliant's facet pattern but in a cushion shape. "Cushion Modified Brilliant" has additional facets in the pavilion — this creates the "crushed ice" appearance: a sparkling, fragmented pattern reminiscent of crushed ice rather than distinct arrows. The choice between them is entirely visual: cushion brilliant (or "antique cushion") produces bold, distinct flashes; cushion modified brilliant produces a sparkling, diffuse shimmer. Neither is objectively better — they are aesthetically different. GIA labels both on the certificate.
For a square cushion: target 1.00:1 to 1.05:1. For a slightly rectangular cushion: 1.08:1 to 1.20:1. Cushions above 1.20:1 appear distinctly rectangular. The most popular range is 1.00:1 to 1.10:1 — providing a classic square appearance with slightly rounded corners. A ratio of exactly 1.00:1 is rare; most square-appearing cushions are 1.01:1 to 1.05:1. See our diamond size chart for face-up dimensions.
Cushion cuts require careful depth management. A deep cushion (depth % above 70–72%) tends to look smaller face-up relative to its carat weight — the extra mass is hidden below the girdle. Target depth: 60–68% for most cushion cuts. Very deep cushions (70%+) sacrifice face-up size for no optical benefit in most cases. Note that GIA does not assign a cut grade to cushion cuts (only to round brilliants), so depth percentage is one of the primary proxy metrics for cut quality evaluation. See our cut grade guide and our depth percentage glossary.
Square cushion cuts rarely exhibit a strong bow-tie — the square outline and distributed facet arrangement means dark zones tend to be much less pronounced than in elongated shapes (oval, marquise, pear). Elongated rectangular cushions (L:W above 1.15:1) may show a mild bow-tie along the long axis, similar to an oval. For square cushions, the bow-tie is generally not a significant evaluation criterion. Focus instead on the overall light return and pattern consistency from face-up imagery. See our bow-tie effect glossary.