Shape Discounts in 2026: Oval and Elongated Cushions Are Back to Parity

The pandemic-era premium on oval and pear shapes has evaporated. Princess and cushions are deeply discounted. Round brilliant holds its floor. Here's the current shape price map and what's driving each movement.

The current shape price map vs round brilliant

Fancy shape pricing is typically expressed as a percentage premium or discount relative to the round brilliant baseline for equivalent carat weight, colour, and clarity. The round brilliant commands the highest price per carat of any shape — it has the deepest, most liquid market and the most standardised grading (GIA grades cut only for rounds). All fancy shapes trade at a discount to rounds, or occasionally at parity.

Using CaratAtlas shape_factor adjustments calibrated against OpenFacet's matrix data (1.0 ct, G VS2, Excellent-equivalent make, August 2026), approximate ranges are:

  • Round brilliant: baseline
  • Oval: −2 % to +4 % (near parity; peaked at +25 % in mid-2022)
  • Pear: −5 % to +2 %
  • Marquise: −8 % to −3 %
  • Elongated cushion: −6 % to −1 %
  • Square cushion: −18 % to −12 %
  • Princess: −22 % to −15 %
  • Emerald: −12 % to −4 %
  • Asscher: −14 % to −6 %
  • Radiant (elongated): −8 % to −3 %

These ranges reflect variance in make quality and market liquidity within each shape category. The best-made examples of any shape trade toward the top of the range; poorly proportioned goods trade at or below the bottom.

Why the oval premium collapsed — and what it means for buyers

The oval premium was driven by a confluence of influencer exposure and celebrity engagement ring news during 2020–2022. When several high-profile engagements featured oval diamonds, the shape became the dominant trend in the bridal market. Vogue's coverage of the oval engagement ring trend and similar mainstream fashion coverage drove a consumer demand spike that caught cutters and dealers with limited inventory of high-quality ovals.

Social media-driven demand spikes are characteristically temporary. As cutters responded by producing more ovals and the trend cycled toward softer shapes (elongated cushions, pears), the premium evaporated. Retailers who accumulated oval inventory at elevated prices are still working through it.

For buyers, this correction is a genuine opportunity. An oval at parity to round gives you a visually larger stone — ovals have more visible surface area for equivalent carat weight, typically 10–12 % more face-up size than a round of the same weight. At equal pricing, the oval is the better value proposition for buyers who prefer the shape. The Gem Society's oval buying guide explains how to evaluate the bow-tie effect and aspect ratios that separate excellent ovals from mediocre ones.

The structural discount on princess and cushion

Princess and cushion cuts carry persistent, structural discounts that are unlikely to reverse. Both shapes suffer from lower market liquidity — fewer active buyers and sellers at any given price point — which depresses valuations relative to rounds. Liquidity matters because it affects how easily you can sell a stone if you ever need to, which in turn affects what buyers will pay today.

Princess cuts have additionally suffered from a fashion cycle headwind: the sharp-cornered square look peaked in the early-to-mid 2000s and is broadly perceived as dated by the current primary bridal buying cohort (millennials and Gen Z). The Knot's annual engagement ring survey has shown round and oval consistently leading purchase shares, with princess declining year over year since 2015.

Square cushions — the most discounted of all major shapes at 12–18 % below round — offer arguably the best value for buyers who prefer a square silhouette. An excellent-make square cushion with strong brilliance in G VS2 can be acquired at a meaningful discount while offering a face-up size comparable to or slightly larger than a round of the same carat weight.

Emerald and Asscher: the step-cut opportunity

Step cuts — emerald and Asscher — trade at discounts to round (−4 % to −14 % depending on make and clarity) but require a different clarity calculus. Step cuts have large, open facets that make inclusions more visible than in brilliant cuts. A VS2 that would be eye-clean in a round brilliant may show visible inclusions in an emerald cut at the same carat weight.

The practical implication: upgrade clarity by one step when buying step cuts relative to your target in brilliants. A VS1 in an emerald cut is roughly equivalent to an SI1 in a round for eye-cleanliness. This extra clarity cost partially offsets the shape discount, but the net result is still typically a price advantage over comparable rounds — and a dramatically different aesthetic that many buyers find more sophisticated.

Pricescope's emerald cut wiki covers the clarity and proportions considerations in detail, including length-to-width ratio guidelines for the most pleasing silhouettes.

Frequently asked questions

Why are oval diamonds no longer more expensive than round?
The oval premium was driven by a social media and celebrity trend spike in 2020–2022. As supply adjusted and the trend normalised, the premium collapsed. Ovals now trade near round parity, making them an excellent value for buyers who prefer the shape — you get more face-up size for the same price. The Gem Society oval guide explains what makes an excellent oval.
Why is the princess cut discounted so heavily?
Princess cuts suffer from declining fashion relevance (the square look peaked in the 2000s) and lower market liquidity compared to rounds. Both factors persistently depress price. The discount is structural rather than cyclical, meaning it is unlikely to reverse.
Do fancy shapes need different clarity grades than rounds?
Yes — step cuts (emerald, Asscher) have larger, open facets that make inclusions more visible. Upgrade clarity by one step relative to your round target: if you'd buy VS2 in a round, buy VS1 in an emerald cut. Brilliant-style fancy shapes (oval, pear, marquise) are closer to round in how they mask inclusions.
Which shape offers the best value right now?
In September 2026, oval (back to round parity with more face-up size) and square cushion (15–20 % below round) offer the strongest value cases. Emerald cut offers a distinctive look at a moderate discount with the caveat of upgrading clarity. Avoid princess if resale matters — liquidity is poor.

TERMS IN THIS NOTE

CutCushion cutEmerald cutAsscher cut shape premiumshape discountfancy shape diamonds